National Partnership for Women & Families

In the News

Murder Conviction Upheld for Man Who Killed Abortion Provider Tiller in 2009

Murder Conviction Upheld for Man Who Killed Abortion Provider Tiller in 2009

October 27, 2014 — The Kansas Supreme Court on Friday upheld the murder conviction of the man who shot abortion provider George Tiller to death in 2009, but the court ordered a resentencing by a lower court because of a technical issue, Reuters reports (Murphy, Reuters, 10/24).

In 2010, Scott Roeder received a life sentence without the chance of parole for 50 years after being convicted of shooting and killing Tiller at the doctor's church in Wichita, Kan. (Women's Health Policy Report, 4/2/2010).

Roeder's Appeal

Roeder acknowledged at his trial that he killed Tiller, but he appealed his first-degree murder conviction and the 50-year sentence.

In his appeal, Roeder argued the jury should have been permitted to consider voluntary manslaughter, a lesser charge, because he believed that killing Tiller was justified to prevent future abortions. The court rejected that claim, as well as Roeder's request for a change of venue.

The court ordered a resentencing hearing because a judge, as opposed to a jury, had imposed the 50-year sentence. In Kansas, only a jury can impose a "Hard 50" sentence, as the punishment is often called. Sedgwick County District Attorney Marc Bennett said he plans to ask the jury for the same sentence (Reuters, 10/24).